Loading Events

🥧 The Great Pumpkin Pie Eating Contest! 🎃

October 31 @ 12:30 pm - 1:00 pm

🥧 The Great Pumpkin Pie Eating Contest! 🎃

Saturday, October 31, 2026 | 12:30PM

Location: Niemann Harvest Market | Carmel, Indiana

Registration: $5 per contestant

Grand Prize: $50 Niemann Harvest Market Gift Card!

Think You’ve Got What It Takes to Be Our Pumpkin Pie Champion? 🏆

Calling all pumpkin pie lovers, competitive eaters, and Halloween thrill-seekers! We’re serving up a deliciously messy showdown during our Harvest Hallows’ Eve celebration, and we want YOU at the table!

Forget the forks, bring your appetite, and get ready to dive face-first into some pumpkin pie fun! 🥧

Whether you’re in it for the glory, the laughs, or the ultimate pumpkin pie bragging rights, this is one Halloween competition you won’t want to miss!

🥧 Here’s What’s at Stake!

🎟️ Entry Fee: Just $5 per contestant

🏆 Grand Prize: $50 Niemann Harvest Market Gift Card

🎃 Bragging Rights: The title of Harvest Hallows’ Eve Pumpkin Pie Eating Champion!

⏰ Contest Begins: 12:30PM

👻 Come Hungry. Leave a Legend.

Think your friends or family members have what it takes? Challenge them to join you! We’ll bring the pie, you bring the competitive spirit, and we’ll see who comes out on top!

Spots are limited, and advance registration is required. Reserve your place at the table today!

🎃 Make a Day of It!

Our Pumpkin Pie Eating Contest is part of Harvest Hallows’ Eve, a family-friendly Halloween celebration happening Saturday, October 31st, from 11AM – 3PM!

Stick around for pumpkin decorating, trick-or-treating, a Halloween scavenger hunt, games, and frightfully delicious food and drink specials!

📅 Saturday, October 31, 2026

⏰ Contest Starts at 12:30PM

📍 Niemann Harvest Market | Carmel, IN

💵 $5 per contestant

🥇 $50 Gift Card Grand Prize

Ready to PIE for the title? Register now and let the pumpkin pie showdown begin! 🎃🥧

Carmel Niemann Harvest Market

2140 E 116th Street
Carmel, IN  46032